Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

Trumpeters 1978 Chevrolet Monte Carlo Landau Coupe

31 posts in this topic

Posted · Report post

Hi

First something to my person: I'm Peter Lepold from Germany, some people here at the board knowing me and/or some my models. I'm building a long time - maybe more than 20 years - model kits. I'm living in Germany and I'm a coach of a successful hand ball youth crew. That's it...! If you want knowing something more, ask me...!

A good boy invited me to write here at the Model Cars board about the Trumpeters 1978 Chevrolet Monte Carlo Landau Coupe. So I do that now. Ah, I want to still say that I am not the best in English language. Therefore please be pardon me if I'm not understandably enough.

Here is something of Trumpeters '78 MC...!

First is, many parts of that kit are are not correct and are made very dearless.

- the floor have no carpet structure (you have to fix it with flocking material)

- headers, intake manifold, enginemount and all the other bigger engine parts have no casting structures like on the original parts (make a comparison with Revell, AMT or old MPC parts)

- no screws and no rivets and bolts at the engine parts (is the engine completely welded together?)

- the front cover with the water pump is missing

- instead two long "amusing" pins coming out form the enginemount on which you have to glue the wheels for the belt drive

- carbuartor is missing, or is this briquette on the intake manifold the carburetor?

- breather cap is missing

- distributor is missing

- the cluster on the instrument panel does not fit

- the hood and the trunk have big dents on the surface, that happens, because Trumpeter did not build enough casting channels at this big parts

- Signatures (like Monte Carlo or Landau) are to filigran

- the roof have no vinyl structures, but it is a Landau Coupe with a half vinyl roof....

- the wheel chrome stripes and the rear window chrome stripes are missing

- the front axle is developed too complicated and is also still wrong from the design

- the rear axle the same (both axles and the completely suspension looked like Trumpeter have measure the original car on the lifting platform, because the axles do not work loaded if a car on the wheels stand), the car is looking like an Off Roader...

...and and and. Result: The model is not worth its money. You must improve much, so that you really get a good model. Now some pictures:

The hood and the trunk with dents

kofferdeckel.jpg

haube.jpg

The filled parts

hauben.jpg

Chromestripes build from sheet

radlauf.jpg

radlauf1.jpg

some other modifications

gravur.jpg

Now the suspension, it is too high (the tires also wrong, they are too small)

radstand1.jpg

Suspension with other tires, but still too high, it is looking like a Offroader

radstand2.jpg

I have shortened the rear shocks (on the right side the new one)

radstand4.jpg

The rear axle/suspension I have corrected

radstand5.jpg

After I have corrected the rear and front suspension

radstand6.jpg

Chassis with new exhaust (from aluminium tube)

unterboden1.jpg

The interior is finished, the steering wheel I took from the old MPC Monte Carlo kit (reissue AMT). I build some details in like belts and some photo eatched parts form Detail Master.

interior1.jpg

interior2.jpg

interior3.jpg

cluster.jpg

Now the engine...you see the arrow, that is showing you what I meant with the cover of the water pump. This big part is missing, I took it also from the old MPC kit. I had plumped and wired the engine, took a carburator and a breather cap from the spare parts and what I have forgotten to tell, the cooling ventilator in the Trumpeter kit is too big, it does not fit into the opening from the radiator...

motor1.jpg

motor2.jpg

motor3.jpg

motor4.jpg

Hope I was understandable enough. In my opinion the kit is not worth its money. Trumpeter built a very dearless model. It is even still worse than the '60 Bonneville. The '60 Bonneville has more love for the detail in the comparison to the MC, although the roof is perfectly wrong.

If you want to see more, please wait a little. I have to sand the hood and trunk again and than I will prime it. I will paint the car white with brwon vinyl roof (like the interior).

Many greetings from Germany

Peter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Peter, welcome! Great and inspiring work on the Monte Carlo 8)

I saw the kit up-close and came to the same conclusions you have; I expect better if they want the market they aim for to take them seriously. Your work to improve the kit is inspiring; I didn't buy the Trumpeter Bonneville until I saw your writeup. Your interior/engine details look very realistic.

Keep us posted with the progress!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Welcome, welcome, welcome Peter! :D

Your review was very informative! I don't know how such glaring problems could have been overlooked..............didn't someone at Trumpeter build this ahead of time and see all of this?? :x

Just the same, this is unacceptable for a kit that costs 35 BUCKS!! :evil:

One thought about the wheels and tires.............American cars out of the '70's typically had wheels and tires that seemed undersized for their respective wheelwell shapes. My Dad had a '79 and I always thought that its wheels were a bit small and too "tucked in" for the size of the vehicle.

That kind of styling would be unacceptable today as some of your compacts are running 16 inchers or better, and the wheels and tires (for the most part) are flush with the bodywork of the fenders

Anyway, keep up the excellent work, and keep us posted!!..............And your english is just fine! :wink:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

I enjoyed viewing your photos of the body repairs and of the meticulous and well done detailing you did to the engine and interior. Very informative and well laid out. Looking forward to seeing this completed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Peter,

First, welcome aboard! You've done all modellers a great service pointing out the flaws in this kit, and you have shown that they can be overcome. I'm looking forward to seeing this model completed, you've done some really nice work on it so far!

Brian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Good morning to all

A small update on the '78 MC before I will to prime and paint the body. You'll see at the pictures the filled and sanded hood an trunk about the dents.

haube1.jpg

kofferdeckel1.jpg

The vinyl structure I made with ethyl acetate and a bristle brush. Here are some pictures from the making of vinyl structure what I did on my '67 Charger (the Revell kit). This kit also have no vinyl roof but it is not a mistake, Chargers are build with and without vinyl roof. But I want to have a Charger with it because I build my best friends original car (it is a "White Hat Special Charger" Edition).

You need ethyl acetate and a bristle brush

vinyl3.jpg

Then you coat the roof with ethyl acetate step by step, and with the old bristle brush you presses the structure into the softened plastic, repeat it until the structure is real. The next pictures are looking "wild"....

vinyl1.jpg

vinyl2.jpg

After painting with semi gloss black the vinyl is looking like this...

vinyl4.jpg

vinyl5.jpg

The same way I did it with the '78 MC.

vinyl.jpg

I tested the vinyl structure with a little of the brown color if the structure is okay. I will remove the color before I prime and paint it.

The headlighst are not good. Too many careless edges and the chrome is not good also. Besides the turn signals are not correct, in the original exist the turn signal glass of a piece, at the model are secondarydivided it.

front.jpg

I will paint the headlights with Alclad chrome, therefore the parts are painted black at the moment.

Greetings from Germany

Peter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Welcome to the board. The work you are showing is great. Do you have anymore Dale Earnhardt cars in the works? He was my favorite also

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Welcome to the board Peter! Your review of the Monte Carlo is exactly what this board needs more of! THAT'S good modeling reference. And your build-up....it looks beautiful! I can't wait to see it finished.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Love the interior and engine work. You are doing a fantastic job with a kit that needs a lot of help.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Thanks for the analysis of the kit's flaws.

I would be irritated having to correct all these problems on a $10 kit, but on a $35 (or more!) item, I'd be furious!

Don't do too good a job on it! I'd hate for Trumpeter to see it and think they did a fantastic job on the kit!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Hi

Thanks to all for the welcome icon14.gif

$35 (or more!) is definitely too much for this kit. I would buy this kit never for $35, perhaps for $10 or less. I want to be honest: I did not pay anything for this kit, that kit I build for the German model magazine "Modell Fan".

It was the same with the '60 Bonneville. Never I would buy this bad kit, but I build it as conception for the German model building magazine.

This magazine (Modell Fan) shows its customer which is wrong at the models. And I'm the man for very "heavy cases" like with the Bonneville and as now with the '78 Monte Carlo. None wants to build so a "muck", I do it....! :wink:

Sometimes I love it to build models like the Trumpeter kits because they are a challenge...! 8)

Greetings from Germany

Peter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

i guess im the only one in the world with this question:

huh? a monte carlo?

why?

i guess they are popular with low riders just because they are cheap and no one else ever wanted one but thats just it: no one else ever wanted one.

like i said, i guess its just me but its beyond my comprehension how any company thinks they are gonna sell these. and thats if it were truly a good replica which it appears it is not.

funny world aint it.

edit: dont mean to discourage or insult those who may think this is a great design or your father had one or something like that, i realize there are various reasons for wanting a model of a car. but from a manufacturers perspective, does anyone think there is a market for this particular vehicle? and the reason for any potential market? it sure aint the most elegant car ever to come off GMs design boards!

so dont take it the wrong way, im just wondering the motivation for a release like this...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

i guess im the only one in the world with this question:

huh? a monte carlo?

why?

Urban legend has it that the person who helped finance the Trumpeter car kits owned a '78 MC, and unless they made the MC, the Nova and Bonneville would not happen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Hi

A small update. Before I prime and paint the body, I build something for a charge. I took the parts (boat and trailer) out of the '70 Bonneville (the reissue from Model King) and detailed the boat.

Thus it looks....

gespann.jpg

I changed the seats to a benachseat and detailed the dashboard. The engine I didn't use, I build a cover from sheet with a scoop.

boot4.jpg

Also I increased the trunk of the boat by three millimeters - the white sheet.

boot5.jpg

The interior is ready.

boot3.jpg

boot2.jpg

Greetings

Peter

@ Marc @ MPC Motorsports: This "story" I heared also...!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Peter, Greetings from the USA!

Thanks for the excellent review and for posting your progress photos.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Thanks for the review Peter. Very factual and well illustrated.

I also enjoyed your review of the '60 Bonneville that you posted a long time ago on another board. Would it be possible to post your Bonneville review and repairs on this board for the benefit of those people who didn't see it before?

A word on subject matter and kit flaws. For my $$ it's all about subject matter. I don't mind making some corrections on kits if I like the subject matter. I bought the Trumpeter Bonneville because I like '60 Pontiacs despite its high price and the many flaws the kit has. The Monte Carlo will not be coming home with me, and that's all I'll say about it.

I hope this Monte kit sells well so that Trumpeter will continue to bring out more American car kits. I really hope that their choice of subject matter combined with the many flaws of this kit will not kill the chances of more future releases. The downside of this is that if the kit does indeed sell well it may turn off future customers who were not expecting all these problems on a premium kit.

I also hope that somebody from Trumpeter reads this board so that they will understand the need to pull up their socks a little in the future. I don't like to trash a kit or manufacturer, but they have to realize that people just will not shell out premium $$ for a kit with so many serious flaws... those are the facts as I see it. Just my 2¢...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Hi

I also enjoyed your review of the '60 Bonneville that you posted a long time ago on another board. Would it be possible to post your Bonneville review and repairs on this board for the benefit of those people who didn't see it before?

@ Mark: Oh, I will try it an article to publish here. It will be difficult and I'm not the best in English language. But I try it.

Greetings from Germany

Peter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Those modifications to the boat are great! Very cool subject, nice combo w/the Monte Carlo...or any suitable tow car.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Thanks, Peter. I can appreciate the language difficulty for you. (By the way, I could easily understand your review of the Monte Carlo.) thumbs.gif

I think a lot of members could benefit from your excellent work for the Bonneville. :D

Sorry for asking you to do something so difficult! :oops:

beer.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

That detail work is so eye-catching, and I really like the way the interiors look on both of these. Super!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Hi there

Here I have a small update, but it is not the MC, it is an update on the boat. The MC needs some time again for drying the filler, a lot of points on the hood and trunk I have to fill and sand.

The boat is nearly finished, some smaller detail works I have to do. I will build a windshild scratch and I will put a name on it - perhaps I will named it "Monte Carlo"..!

All the "wooden" is painted, first I painted with airbrush a base color (dark brwon) and than I painted the wooden structure with drybrushing and detail painting with different brushes and different brown colors.

It needs a lot of time, but i think it is looking nearly like real wooden.

boot10.jpg

boot11.jpg

boot6.jpg

boot7.jpg

At the "hood" I put a photo eatched part with the signature "SS 454"...!

boot8.jpg

The rear view (with the real US-flag :wink: ).

boot9.jpg

The “ornament†on the sides, on the back and at the hood are decals from the Revell '70 Custom Van. The top side of the boat was chromium-plated with BMF aluminum.

Now the trailer..! The small tail lamps and the “rubbers†were supplemented on the rails, because the bottom of the boat would not to be scratched when the loading and unloading! The rims are Monte Carlo rims of the MPC Monte Carlo!

trailer1.jpg

trailer2.jpg

trailer3.jpg

Painted in aluminium.

Greetings

Peter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

:shock: :shock: That's painted wood???

You coulda fooled me..........you got that grain of the wood so perfect!! :D

Excellent job as usual Peter! That boat will be a great compliment to the Monte!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

That boat is awesome. Beautiful workmanship.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Hello to all

I'm sorry that I was not present here the last time. Now the '78 Monte Carlo is finished. Her some pics.

First some pics of the last progress:

Finished (without hood).

Bild1.jpg

I'm add some water skis on the trunk.

Bild2.jpg

Here you'll see a little of the vinyl structure.

Bild3.jpg

Flashlights are not correct at the kit, first look at the original car.

original.JPG

Trumpeter made a chrome prop between the front and the side flasher doof.gif.

Bild4.jpg

Bild5.jpg

Here are the completely finished car (without trailer/boat). I have to make pics of it (of all, boat and car) when the weather is more better. We have very heavy snow and it is not good to make good pics with the lighting conditions at the moment.

fertig.jpg

Cheers from Germany

Peter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

i guess im the only one in the world with this question:

huh? a monte carlo?

why?

it sure aint the most elegant car ever to come off GMs design boards!

Hell, the hummer rolled out o GMs factories, the monte aint that bad lookin,

in fact IMO it looks pretty damned good!, compare it with european and

asian cars from the same time!! and those that followed duuring the 80's,

european and asian cars during the 80's looked like ###### 4REAL, did anyone

ACTUALLY even design them??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0