You win, too.
We can go one of 3 ways:
A. No off-topic posts, period (let's call this the Ken solution)...
B. Create a specific area only for off topic posts.
C. Limit any off-topic posts to a designated area (General Topics).
Solution A accommodates one certain group of members and alienates another group.
Solution B (which I think is what Pat is driving at) is unnecessary, IMO, as we already have a spot for "other" posts (General Topics).
Solution C accommodates everyone. Or in other words, leave things as they are!
My 2¢, for what it's worth.
But I'll be happy to go with whatever the majority wants.