I would pick the AMT because of the body style (Sport Coupe, no A-pillar), so this is just personal preference. I also recommend buying the photo etch detail set from Model Car Garage in case the kit doesn´t include photo etch parts. I have built the so called Custom Culture Series version and have the AMT/Ertl Pro Shop version in the stash. Both do have photo etch parts included. Whatever you choose the result will be a fifties icon!