I'd mostly give it to the AMT kit, with some caveats: - The Vanishing Point parts (new stock hood with no hole, "Hemi" parts for the engine, Rallye wheels) are, well- yuck. The hood looks a little bizarre even compared to the hole-in-hood Yankee Challenge version. You'd be better off filling the hole in the Yankee Challenge hood. Look at them side-by-side and you will see what I mean. The Hemi engine parts are WAY off, laughable and unusable (think: 440 valve covers with little bumps), but then again, Hemis are terribly common in 1/25 scale, so if you must have a Hemi, you could find a better one in almost any other Hemi kit. The Rallyes aren't too bad, but better ones can be had. I think the last VP issue also included the old Magnum 500 wheels (good ones), and the old hood with the hole in it, along with the 440 Six Pack parts, so let's hope Round 2 includes this stuff with the reissue. -The interior is so-so, at best. The Dash is the pretty bad, but once installed, it might not bother you. You could get a better dash from almost any other Cuda or Challenger kit. -You would have to graft the roof onto the body to build it. It's a separate vinyl textured roof, so if you want no vinyl roof, you'll have to knock the vinyl texture off. Also, you would have to bond and fill the leading edge of the roof to the windshield frame. It can be done, but it will take considerable work. -The kit comes with a Dana axle. Not many 1:1 Challengers were equipped this way, an 8-3/4 was much more common. Not too much of a drawback, really. -The headlights look a little funky. Cut the mounting bosses off of the backs, and maybe drill out and foil the buckets to make them look better. To it's credit, I think the body proportions are much better in the AMT kit than the Revell kit. Also, the 440 Six Pack, while basic, at least looks the part. This kit is the only source I know of for Chrome-plated Rallye mirrors (which could be used on many 70's Mopars), and- if you want to build a convertible, as long as the boot is included, it's much easier to go that route than a hardtop with this kit. The chassis is fairly nice, again- looks the part. The Revell kit is just wrong-looking enough to my eyes, but I did build one of the VP diecasts. It looks OK on the shelf, if a little porky. The metal axle thru the block doesn't bother me as much as the shrimpy tires, and the chassis plate that doesn't seem to want to settle in under the body. The details are pretty nice with the Revell kit- the chassis, while still simple, maybe looks a bit better than the AMT kit. The interior is pretty nice. The engine, while simple, has a nice 440 4-BBL air cleaner. You have the option to build a T/A with the Revell kit, and it has everything you need, except for the engine. The 440 block is used - 4BBL for the R/T option, 440 Six Pack for the T/A, while you would need a 340 Six Pack for the T/A. The one thing I really like about the Revell kit is: the interior side panels show power window buttons instead of cranks. Again- there are many 70's Mopar applications for these; they could always be foil-cast from these side panels and used on an AMT '71 Charger or '74 Road Runner, for examples.