I'd like to reiterate my point. I wasn't saying specifically that a shiny paint job is what knocks a field down to a manageable number but rather the quality of the finish. The standards of judging paint work still apply, no orange peel, chips, fingerprints etc. However a great shine is a plus in nearly every category and a great shine will put you over the guy without one if the quality of the paint work are more or less equal.
After the finish, then the judges start looking at the cleanliness of the build. If the cleanliness isn't there, they are thrown back like undersized fish. A sloppy build is a deal breaker regardless of your finish. If we no longer have enough builds for first, second, third, then the judges revisit the builds that were originally removed from contention to see if they need to move up based on cleanliness of build. After all this, then they take into account customizing, scratch building, detailing, accuracy and general wow factor.
These are the standards of contest judging. I have had long discussions with club members all over Florida. A solid finish and clean building are what wins contests. It is a beauty contest. No question. You might have super-researched the long forgotten 1 of 1, '64 Whatchacallit with the rare neon lime green paint and the optional dinglewhopper, but if your finish isn't tight and the build isn't clean, then it's just another undersized fish on the table.