Dave,
I will tell you getting a nice painted finish on the body is the biggest challenge for beginning modelers. So I would suggest you find a kit where the body is one color basic. Notice the black trim around the windows on the 458 kit you referenced, you will need to paint that so it may not be a good starting point. Although an older body style (maybe a '32 Ford) might not be the type of car you are interested in but it would be a good starting choice. Something without a lot of chrome details on the body because again you will need to paint these details or apply self adhesive metal foil.
A NASCAR kit might also be a good starter because the car is usually one basic color with all the graphics included as decals.
I would not spend anywhere near $200 trying to build your first kit. You should be able to get the kit, glue and various paints (spray paint for the body and brush paint for various details) for around $60.
When you are selecting a kit look for something with a Skill Level 2 or below. The higher the Skill Level number the more challenging the kit will be to build.
Hope this helps and good luck.
JC