If anyone is interested in my opinion, a lot of the time where you end up is due to where you started. What I mean by this is that if one company is basing its kit on a drawing that may or may not be accurate, this company will likely end up in a different place than a company that has the final car and is taking measurements from it. One other thing to keep in mind is that we are all fallible human beings and mistakes can happen. Once a measurement is wrong in one place, it can ripple throughout the whole process.
There have been a number of references to the military builders and how they demand everything to be accurate; whereas, the car guys are not that serious about accuracy. If you think about it, the reason the military builders have to be concerned about accuracy is that there is only one correct way to build their kits. One cannot paint a tank a candy apple color or swap out an engine in a Sherman for one that was in a Panzer. This is a bit of a silly example, but I do think there is some relevance. Car guys don’t think twice before doing something like this, and further, it has been done in the 1:1 world.
One other thing about military modelers is that they usually build only one of their kits. I have not seen many military modelers that have multiple F-15’s on their shelves. They have one or perhaps two if there is certain significance with a fighter squadron. Or they may have different scales of the same model, but I have never seen half dozen different renditions of the same plane. On the other hand I have seen multiple versions of the same car on builders’ shelves.
The other piece to this is price. I don’t think I am that different from others, but price does matter. I don’t think that makes me cheap, but like everyone else, I have a certain amount of money I can spend on what is a hobby. Once prices get above a certain threshold, I have to think long and hard as to whether I want to spend that amount of money. There has to be a Tamiya kit out there that really grabs my attention to think about spending $50.00 for a model. I fully expect the $50.00 kit to be better engineered, scaled more accurately and should construct better than one at $25.00. However, many of us can make that $25.00 model look real nice.
This is long winded, and for those who read all of it without being bored or going to sleep – thanks.